Carmine’s Pizzeria

Carmine’s Pizzeria is a must-visit spot nestled in Appomattox, VA, renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza. Patrons rave about the taste and quality, with many reviewers returning to reminisce about their time in the Bronx. David Quillen captured the essence of Carmine’s when he declared it had the best pizza he had found, prompting him to take home an extra pie. John Zeh echoes this sentiment, wishing he had discovered the pizzeria sooner.

What sets Carmine’s apart is not only the pizza but also the exceptional value and friendly service. William Walker highlights the large portions like the garden salad enhanced with chicken, offering a fresh and satisfying side to complement the main dish. Ace Bailey insists that Carmine’s buffalo pizza is the best he’s ever tasted, reinforcing that this isn't just another local option amidst many chain restaurants.

Even self-proclaimed pizza aficionados like Umi Ugs, who typically lean towards Chicago’s thin crust, found themselves dreaming about Carmine’s offerings. From its perfectly baked pies to delightful desserts like freshly filled cannoli, Carmine’s Pizzeria promises an unforgettable dining experience that bridges the gap between taste and nostalgia.